Skip to content

( Should you )

A second home in JB: is it worth it for Singaporeans?

· Updated · Bodaiju Residences Medini

Short answer. Not as a weekend place that pays for itself.

If you hold the state’s go-ahead for the purchase in writing, a two-bedroom in Medini costs about RM12,600 a year to own, before you furnish it or switch on a light.

A similar apartment nearby was asking about RM254 a night when we checked.

That works out to at least 50 nights a year.

Count what the cash could have earned sitting in CPF, and it is at least 93.

“At least” because the room you book comes furnished and cleaned, and the home you own arrives empty, so the sofa and the power bill come on top.

The yearly cost starts from the four bills that repeat every year you own, then adds the fees you pay once.

The building is still going up, so none of these nights start until handover, which the current dates put in 2027 to 2028.

13 nights. Yearly bill only. Maintenance and sinking fund, RM3,180 a year
50 or more. Plus one-off fees. Spread over 10 years, RM12,581 a year
93 or more. Plus lost CPF interest. 2.5% a year, RM23,581 a year
RM254. A night nearby. Our sampled weekend median, 14 Nov 2026
A worked example for one two-bedroom, with the one-off fees spread over ten years and taken at the below-RM1m category's fees. Every assumption is listed under the main table.

At Bank Negara Malaysia’s 5pm middle rate on 13 November 2026, RM3.1749 to S$1, RM12,581 is about S$3,963, RM23,581 is about S$7,427, and RM254 is about S$80.

Before the sums: can you buy at all?

Johor’s floor for foreign buyers is RM1,000,000, and the land office’s own page applies that floor to serviced apartments too.

It names no exception.

The state’s fee list also prices an approval for a serviced apartment sold below RM1,000,000 with the state’s go-ahead, so that kind of approval exists.

We have not found a public document naming a project or a unit that has it.

Neither land office page names one as at 14 November 2026, and nothing in the project material we reviewed up to 17 August 2026 does either.

So ask for the paper for your own unit, and have your own Malaysian lawyer read it before you look at the sums below.

The longer version is in whether there is a minimum price for foreigners in Medini.

What owning costs each year

Only one of these bills turns up every month.

The example is a 753 sq ft two-bedroom at RM440,000, the lowest two-bedroom price on this site.

The bills that repeat

Maintenance plus the sinking fund, the building’s repair savings pot, comes to about RM265 a month, or RM3,180 a year.

That is the developer’s estimate from sales material dated 13 January 2026, at RM0.32 per sq ft plus 10%.

The building’s management body sets the real figure after completion.

The council’s yearly bill is charged at 0.18% for serviced apartments on the council’s own published table, on a value the council works out itself.

Nobody knows the ringgit amount until the council values the finished building.

The land office’s yearly bill is worked out per square metre, and we do not know the rate for this kind of title.

Electricity, water, internet and contents insurance are not priced anywhere on this site.

Only the maintenance line goes into the base sum.

The fees you pay once

About RM94,006 on top of the price, once, at the below-RM1m category’s fees.

RM89,200 goes to the government at those fees: stamp duty at 8%, plus the state’s consent fee at that category’s RM50,000 minimum, the application for it and the fee to register the transfer, all three on Johor’s fee list.

In the public material reviewed for this site, as at 14 November 2026, no project-level document places Bodaiju or any unit in that category, so this is a worked example at that category’s fees, not a quote for your unit.

RM4,806 goes on legal fees and the service tax on them.

The 8% is the rate the Finance Act 2025 sets for a buyer who is neither a Malaysian citizen nor a permanent resident, on home transfers signed from 1 January 2026.

For scale, RM94,006 is about 370 nights at RM254.

At three nights a month, that is about ten years of stays, paid for before you own a single chair.

The money that sits there

The CPF Ordinary Account pays 2.5% a year for October to December 2026.

The CPF Board says you cannot spend CPF savings on a home overseas, so we are only borrowing the rate.

2.5% of RM440,000 is RM11,000 a year.

That overstates the early years.

Malaysia’s standard sale contract for a home bought before it is built sets the payments by stage: 10% at signing, RM44,000 here, and the rest as the building goes up.

The full RM440,000 is only tied up from handover.

We do not know what your own cash would really have earned, or where the ringgit goes.

So every result below is shown with this line and without it.

Is a second home in JB worth it? The sum

Stay fewer nights than this and booking is cheaper.

What you countYearly costNights at RM254 (weekend median)At RM203.50 (weekday)At RM277 (holiday weekend)
Yearly bill only: maintenance and sinking fundRM3,180131612
Plus one-off fees, spread over 10 yearsRM12,581506246
Plus lost CPF interest, 2.5% a year on RM440,000RM23,5819311686
Fees, plus furniture and bills (our guess)RM16,981678462
Fees and CPF interest, plus furniture and bills (our guess)RM27,981111138102

Nights are always rounded up to the next whole night.

Nights a year needed before owning costs less than booking at RM254 a night 13 nights on the maintenance bill alone, 50 nights once the one-off fees are spread over ten years, 93 nights once 2.5% a year on the purchase price is counted too. Yearly bill only 13 RM3,180 a year Plus one-off fees 50 RM12,581 a year Plus lost CPF interest 93 RM23,581 a year
Nights a year at RM254 a night, for the first three rows of the table. Furnishing and running bills are not in these bars. It assumes you hold the state's written go-ahead for the purchase. Our arithmetic, on the assumptions listed below.

So 13 nights covers the one bill we know.

The honest number starts at 50.

None of the sources on this page publishes this number. We did the dividing ourselves.

The first three rows are a bare unit, while RM254 buys an apartment with the furniture in and the air-con running.

The two “our guess” rows close part of that gap with two inputs we made up: RM20,000 of furnishing spread over ten years, and RM200 a month for power, water and wifi.

Nobody has given us a furnishing price for this building, so neither figure is a quote.

Assessment, insurance and cleaning after each stay are still missing from those rows.

Against a serviced residence the bar is lower.

Somerset Medini showed RM336 a night on two of our date pairs and RM390 on the other two.

At RM336, the answer is 38 nights on the fees and 71 with CPF interest.

At RM390, it is 33 and 61.

What we left out, and roughly how much it adds

  • Every RM10,000 of furnishing, spread over 10 years, adds about 4 nights a year.
  • Every RM100 a month of running bills adds about 5 nights a year.
  • Assessment, as an illustration only: the council’s published rate for serviced apartments is 0.18%, and if it valued the unit at the RM440,000 purchase price, that would be RM792 a year, or about 3 nights. The value it will really use is not known.

What the sum assumes

  1. The home: a 753 sq ft two-bedroom at RM440,000, the lowest two-bedroom price on this site.
  2. The buyer: a Singapore citizen, not a Malaysian permanent resident, paying cash, with the state’s written go-ahead in hand.
  3. Maintenance is the developer’s January 2026 estimate. Assessment and parcel rent are left out because the amounts are not known.
  4. The one-off fees use today’s law, at the below-RM1m category’s fees, including its RM50,000 minimum consent fee. In the public material reviewed for this site, as at 14 November 2026, no project-level document places Bodaiju or any unit in that category. The later fees follow the law in force when the title is issued.
  5. Ten years is our choice. Five and fifteen are in the appendix.
  6. 2.5% is the CPF Ordinary Account rate, for comparison only. The “plus one-off fees” row is the answer without it.
  7. The home sells later for what you paid. We had to pick something, so we picked no gain and no loss.
  8. RM254 is our own small price check on one day. Put in what you pay.
  9. Left out, and all of it makes owning cost more: furnishing and running bills (rough sizes above), repairs, insurance, loan interest, currency moves, an agent and a lawyer when you sell, the later legal fee for putting the title in your name (this site’s estimate is RM650 to RM1,900), and the stretch during construction when money goes in and there are no nights to use.

Clause 33(3) of the standard sale contract says the developer bears the cost of obtaining state consent to the transfer, and whether that covers this consent fee is arguable.

If it does, the one-off total falls by RM52,540 to RM41,466. We have used the costlier reading.

Your own number

  1. Your yearly cost: RM12,581 (about S$3,963) to start. Add RM1,000 for every RM10,000 of furnishing and RM1,200 for every RM100 a month of bills. Add RM11,000 (about S$3,465) if you count what the cash could have earned.
  2. Your price per night today: take your last three JB bookings and average them. The asking price we sampled was RM254 (about S$80).
  3. Divide line 1 by line 2. That is the nights you need each year. If you really stay fewer, booking costs less.

What a night costs today: our price check

We checked twice on 14 November 2026, Malaysia time, a few hours apart.

The search was Airbnb, area “Medini, Iskandar Puteri”, 4 guests, at least 2 bedrooms, prices in ringgit with all fees included.

We took the first page of results in Airbnb’s default order, 18 listings, and kept the two-bedroom ones.

Airbnb showed “over 1,000 homes in Iskandar Puteri” each time.

A thousand homes. We read 18.

A night is the two-night total, halved.

Stay, 2 nightsSchools: Singapore / JohorListings, 1st check / 2ndLowestMedian, 1st / 2ndHighest
Fri 27 to Sun 29 Nov 2026, 2 weeks aheadHoliday / in term17 / 16RM193.50RM247 / RM250.50RM400
Fri 11 to Sun 13 Dec 2026, 4 weeks aheadHoliday / holiday14 / 13RM159RM277 / RM273.50RM351
Fri 15 to Sun 17 Jan 2027, 9 weeks aheadIn term / in term14 / 14RM160RM250.50 / RM250.50RM585.50
Tue 19 to Thu 21 Jan 2027, 9 weeks aheadIn term / in term13 / 13RM120RM203.50 / RM203.50RM318.50

RM254 is the median of the three weekends pooled, and it came out the same on both checks: 45 listings, then 43.

RM203.50 is the weekday median, and RM277 is the December weekend on the first check.

The RM585.50 is an eight-person garden villa at RM1,171 for the two nights, which is one way to define a two-bedroom.

We left it in so the count is honest. Take it out and that weekend’s median stays at RM250.50, and the pooled figure moves by 50 sen.

Where this check is weak:

  • These are asking prices for nights nobody has booked yet. They are not what anyone paid.
  • The four stays sit 2, 4 and 9 weeks ahead, so holiday against term is tangled up with how far ahead you book. January can include early-booking discounts.
  • Airbnb’s default order is a ranking. Page one is not a random draw from a thousand homes, and it changes by a listing or two between sessions.
  • Both checks were on the same day.
  • Two bedrooms on Airbnb and one hotel room are different things.

The hotel check ran once, on Booking.com: 2 adults, 1 room, cheapest room shown, taxes and charges possibly extra.

A search for “Medini, Iskandar Puteri” matched one property in Medini itself, Somerset Medini Iskandar Puteri, at the RM336 and RM390 used above.

From the same results, Kingston Hotel 16 near Legoland showed RM84 to RM163 a night, and Legoland Malaysia Hotel RM950 to RM1,450, which makes every other figure on this page look thrifty.

Every price, so you can recompute RM254

Two-night totals in ringgit, two-bedroom listings, first check, lowest first.

27 to 29 Nov 2026 (17): 387, 400, 420, 436, 441, 445, 465, 471, 494, 508, 512, 516, 526, 536, 536, 555, 800.

11 to 13 Dec 2026 (14): 318, 460, 471, 508, 532, 536, 547, 561, 596, 606, 618, 659, 700, 702.

15 to 17 Jan 2027 (14): 320, 419, 431, 442, 486, 498, 501, 501, 506, 506, 508, 518, 586, 1171.

19 to 21 Jan 2027 (13): 240, 262, 325, 329, 344, 362, 407, 416, 434, 447, 454, 487, 637.

On the second check the 471 listing had dropped off the November page and the 659 listing off the December page. The two January pages were unchanged.

Halve each figure, pool the first three lines (45 numbers), and take the middle one. It is RM254.

How many nights will you really use?

Every weekend, two nights at a time, is 104 nights a year.

Two weekends a month is 48, and one a month is 24.

At 24 nights, each night in your own home works out to RM524 on the fees alone, about double the RM254 asking price down the road.

Double, and you still have to buy the sofa.

The crossing is what trims the count.

ICA cleared close to 245 million travellers in 2025, about 76% of them at the land checkpoints.

A record of more than 598,000 people crossed by land in one day, on 19 June 2026.

Across the holiday stretch from 26 May to 28 June 2026, ICA says car travellers waited up to three hours at peak hours.

The Bodaiju site is about 9 km by road from the Sultan Abu Bakar checkpoint on the Second Link, via the Second Link Expressway (E3), measured 3 November 2026.

We publish no travel time.

Try your own crossing at the hours you would really travel, a few weekends running.

If you drive, every foreign-registered vehicle entering Peninsular Malaysia must be registered for a Vehicle Entry Permit.

The processing fee is RM10, the tag lasts 5 years, and private cars pay a RM20 road charge on each entry.

RM20 a trip. Small. It is still not in our sum.

Since 1 July 2025, owners without a registered or activated permit get a summons, payable before they leave Malaysia.

Malaysia’s Immigration Department lists Singapore nationals as not needing a visa to enter.

You do not need Malaysia My Second Home to buy or to visit, and buying gives you no right to stay.

On 2 October 2026, LTA and Malaysia’s transport ministry said the operator now expects passenger service in February 2027, if the safety sign-off and final approvals come through.

LTA describes a 4 km train ride of about five minutes between Woodlands North and Bukit Chagar in JB.

It does not serve Medini.

The nearest figure we have measured is to the JB checkpoint, not the station: about 21 km by road from Mall of Medini to Bangunan Sultan Iskandar, via Route 52, measured 10 August 2026.

Fares, the opening day and how you would get from the station to Medini are not published.

Use it 30 nights, rent it out the rest

If RoomGuru rents the apartment out for you, your own nights are capped.

The terms, as their agreement stands today:

  • A one-year operating agreement, from the day the unit first opens for booking, renewing yearly.
  • You keep up to 30 nights a year, on dates guests have not already booked.
  • You are paid a share of what the unit actually earns after platform fees. There is no fixed income and no minimum payout.
  • Ending it without cause in year one costs an administration fee. After that, either side can end it on 30 days’ notice.
  • The fee and the furnishing price are given in writing and are not published.

Thirty nights does not get you to 50.

So your own stays cannot carry the cost, and the rental has to.

It is a rental unit you borrow for a month a year.

If you want your own place every other weekend, this agreement does not give you that.

Your nights are the ones guests did not book, so mostly not the peak weekends, and the weekday price is the fairer way to value them.

Your 30 nights valued atWorthGap, counting lost CPF interestGap on the fees alone
The weekday priceRM6,105RM17,476 a year, about RM1,456 a monthRM6,476 a year, about RM540 a month
The weekend priceRM7,620RM15,961 a year, about RM1,330 a monthRM4,961 a year, about RM413 a month

Take the first row: RM17,476 a year is what has to be left for you after RoomGuru’s share, cleaning, power, platform fees and Malaysian tax, before you have furnished the place.

Nobody can promise you that figure.

We publish no occupancy or income projection for Bodaiju.

At the seven Medini apartments RoomGuru manages, Friday and Saturday were the busiest days to arrive: 242 of 606 stays, check-ins November 2025 to October 2026, read 14 November 2026.

Those are the nights you want too.

Bodaiju is sold on a service apartment title, the category the developer sells on for nightly letting.

The title alone does not settle it.

The building’s management body does not exist yet, so its house rules are unwritten.

The owners of a building can vote to restrict short stays.

In Innab Salil v Verve Suites Mont’ Kiara (2020), Malaysia’s Federal Court upheld one management body’s house rule against short-term letting, in a building on commercial title, and we set out the layers that decide whether Airbnb is allowed in Medini separately.

It costs nothing to ask: have your lawyer confirm the short-stay terms in your sale contract, in writing.

Malaysia’s tax office sets the non-resident rate on rental income at 30% of what is left after allowed costs.

In Singapore, IRAS says overseas income received by an individual is generally not taxable, with listed exceptions such as income received through a Singapore partnership.

If a rental unit with a month of your own sounds about right, do not start with a brochure.

Ask RoomGuru for two things: twelve months of real records from homes they already run, weak months included, and the agreement in writing.

Read both knowing that other homes in other buildings are not a forecast for this one.

Then see what RoomGuru’s management covers, and what it asks of you.

What people on the forums worry about, checked

The worries are paraphrased from a Seedly thread, a HardwareZone thread and a CNA feature, all opened on 14 November 2026.

The worryWhat we can say
"Hard to sell"On the tax office's table, a foreign seller pays tax on the gain at 30% in years one to five and 10% from year six, never zero. And it is a 99-year lease, not freehold, running to 27 December 2114
"Too much supply, no price growth"Johor held 9,477 unsold serviced apartments at the end of 2025, the most of any state, on NAPIC's state table. Our sum assumes no price gain at all
"Buildings get run down"The maintenance figure is an estimate and the management body does not exist yet. Nobody can show how this building will be run
"The jam. You stop going"ICA's figure of up to three hours at peak, above, is the official one. Fewer trips means a higher cost for each night you do stay
"The ringgit"The sum is in ringgit, with one dated rate. We say nothing about which way it moves
"Just rent, don't buy"The main table is that comparison. At RM254 a night, over a ten-year hold, unfurnished and before any CPF interest, booking costs less below 50 nights a year

When the answer is no

  1. Your HDB flat is still inside its Minimum Occupation Period (MOP), the years you must live in it. HDB does not let owners, spouses or occupiers acquire private residential property, in Singapore or overseas, during that time. It is 5 years for standard flats and 10 for Plus and Prime flats, and signing a sale agreement counts even if the unit is not built.
  2. You may want an HDB flat again later. To buy a flat from HDB, a resale Plus or Prime flat, or a resale flat with a CPF housing grant, you must not own private residential property in Singapore or overseas, or have disposed of one in the 30 months before you apply. For a resale flat with no subsidy, the 15-month wait was removed on 28 July 2026, but the overseas home must still go within six months of completing the purchase. Seniors buying a short-lease 2-room Flexi flat or a Community Care Apartment from HDB are treated differently. So a home in JB can keep you out of a new HDB flat for two and a half years after you sell it.
  3. You want it as your own weekend place and also need the rental to pay for it. The agreement leaves you 30 nights.
  4. You would stay fewer than about 50 nights a year and do not want guests in it. At RM254 a night and a ten-year hold, booking costs less.
  5. You may need the money back within five years. RM94,006 in fees, at the below-RM1m category’s fees, comes first, and any gain is taxed at 30%.
  6. You want weekends there now. MGB, the main contractor, targets November 2027 for the first phase, the developer’s sales kit says 24 months from the date of your SPA, and the statutory estimate on the KPKT advertising permit is August 2028.

Who the sums are kinder to

Someone who already crosses most weekends on the Tuas side gets closest to the 50.

The sums assume a hold of ten years or more, and at five years the 50 becomes 87.

The 30-night arrangement only fits a buyer who wanted a rental unit with a month of their own in the first place.

Appendix: the other two tables

The main table spreads the one-off fees over ten years.

Hold for less and each year carries more of them.

Hold forFees only, a yearNightsWith CPF interest, a yearNights
5 yearsRM21,98187RM32,981130
10 yearsRM12,58150RM23,58193
15 yearsRM9,44738RM20,44781

Turn the sum round and you get what each of your own nights costs, over a ten-year hold.

Nights you stay a yearFees only, per nightWith CPF interest, per night
24, one weekend a monthRM524RM983
30, the most RoomGuru's agreement leaves youRM419RM786
48, two weekends a monthRM262RM491
104, every weekendRM121RM227

What we could not verify

  1. Assessment and parcel rent in ringgit. The council’s rate and basis were opened on 14 November 2026, but the amount needs its value for the finished building. The land office’s explainer gives only simulated rates (RM1.90 per m² for Pangsapuri Perkhidmatan); the official rate for this title’s express condition was not published as at 14 November 2026.
  2. A project-level document for a purchase below RM1,000,000. The land office’s two pages name no project and no unit as at 14 November 2026.
  3. What furnishing and running bills will really cost here. Nobody has priced them for this building, so we guessed, and said so.
  4. A full-year nightly price. Ours is one day’s check.
  5. Travel time. ICA’s figure covers peak hours in one holiday period, and we have no sample of our own.
  6. The house rules of an unfinished building, and RoomGuru’s share and furnishing price, which are given in writing on request.
  7. The RTS Link opening day. February 2027 is the operator’s expectation as reported on 2 October 2026.

Where this comes from

All opened on 14 November 2026.

Ours is the worked example.

Run it with your own nights and your own prices.

This is general information, not financial, tax or legal advice.

Common questions

Can I buy a place in JB while I still own an HDB flat?

Only after the years you must live in the flat first.

HDB does not let flat owners, spouses or occupiers acquire private residential property, in Singapore or overseas, during the Minimum Occupation Period (MOP): 5 years for standard flats and 10 for Plus and Prime flats.

Signing the sale agreement counts, even if the unit is still being built.

Does a home in Johor count when Singapore works out stamp duty on my next home here?

No. For Additional Buyer's Stamp Duty, the extra duty on second and later homes, IRAS excludes all residential properties outside Singapore from the count.

Can I stay in my own unit whenever I like if RoomGuru rents it out?

No. You keep up to 30 nights a year, on dates guests have not already booked.

How bad is the checkpoint on a weekend?

It varies.

ICA says that at peak hours during the holiday stretch from 26 May to 28 June 2026, car travellers waited up to three hours. The busiest single day in that stretch, 19 June, saw more than 598,000 people cross by land.

Is rent from a Malaysian home taxed again in Singapore?

Generally not for an individual. IRAS says overseas income received in Singapore is not taxable, with a short list of exceptions such as income received through a Singapore partnership.

Malaysia taxes it first: its tax office sets the non-resident rate at 30% of what is left after allowed costs.

Don't take our word for it. Take the half-day trip, stand in the unit, and decide for yourself.